· toilet lid replacement · 13 min read
Best Toilet Lid Replacements for Every Budget in 2024
Finding the perfect toilet lid replacement can be a daunting task. With so many options on the market, it can be hard to know where to start. That's why we've put together this guide to the best toilet lid replacements in 2024. We'll cover everything you need to know, from the different types of toilet lids to the features to look for.
Finding the perfect toilet lid replacement can be a daunting task. With so many options on the market, it can be hard to know where to start. That's why we've put together this guide to the best toilet lid replacements in 2024. With the best toilet lid, your toilet will not only function better but also upgrade the whole toilet to a better look!
Overview

PROS
- Easy to install - simply lift off the old lid and place the new one on.
- Made of durable wood that will last for years.
- Comfortable to sit on, with a contoured seat and lid.
- Cleans easily with a damp cloth.
- Available in a variety of colors to match your bathroom décor.
CONS
- A bit expensive compared to other toilet lids.
- The white color may show dirt and grime more easily than other colors.
The Bemis 1500EC 390 Lift-Off Wood Elongated Toilet Seat is the perfect replacement for your old, broken toilet lid. It's easy to install - simply lift off the old lid and place the new one on. It's made of durable wood that will last for years, and it's comfortable to sit on, with a contoured seat and lid. It cleans easily with a damp cloth, and it's available in a variety of colors to match your bathroom décor.
That said, the Bemis 1500EC 390 is a bit expensive compared to other toilet lids, and the white color may show dirt and grime more easily than other colors. But overall, it's a great choice for a replacement toilet lid.

PROS
- Experience unparalleled comfort with its elongated design, providing ample space and support.
- Enjoy a peaceful bathroom ambiance with its Quiet-Close feature, eliminating slamming and startling noises.
- Effortless installation with Quick-Attach hardware, making it a breeze to replace your old toilet seat.
- Secure and stable fit ensured by Grip-Tight Bumpers, preventing unwanted shifting or movement.
CONS
- May require additional hardware or tools for certain toilet models.
- The white color may not match all bathroom décor preferences.
Kohler's Brevia Elongated Toilet Seat is a premium replacement option that combines comfort, convenience, and durability. Its elongated design offers a more spacious and supportive seating surface, making it ideal for those seeking maximum comfort. The Quiet-Close feature is a game-changer, as it gently lowers the seat and lid, eliminating the annoying slamming sound. Installation is a breeze thanks to the Quick-Attach hardware, making it easy to replace your old seat without any hassle.
The Grip-Tight Bumpers provide a secure and stable fit, ensuring that the seat remains firmly in place. However, it's worth noting that additional hardware or tools may be required for certain toilet models. Overall, the Kohler K-20110-0 Brevia Elongated Toilet Seat is an excellent choice for those seeking a comfortable, quiet, and easy-to-install toilet seat replacement. Its elegant white finish complements most bathroom décor, making it a stylish and functional addition to your bathroom.

PROS
- Durable plastic construction ensures longevity and easy cleaning
- Slow-close mechanism prevents slamming and reduces noise
CONS
- May require some assembly
- Check dimensions to ensure compatibility with your toilet bowl
Introducing the Mayfair Caswell Modern Toilet Seat, the perfect solution for upgrading your bathroom with both style and functionality. Crafted from durable plastic, this replacement lid offers long-lasting performance while being exceptionally easy to clean. Its modern design adds a touch of sophistication to your bathroom décor.
One of the standout features of this toilet seat is its slow-close mechanism. No more accidental slamming or loud noises! It gently lowers the lid and seat, providing a quieter and more controlled experience. Furthermore, the contoured shape ensures a comfortable seating position.

PROS
- Durable and long-lasting construction
- Easy to install and clean
CONS
- May not fit all toilet tanks perfectly
- Can be expensive
If you're looking for a replacement toilet lid, the American Standard 735121-400.020 Cadet 3 Toilet Tank Lid is a great option. It's made of durable materials and is easy to install and clean. It also comes with a 1-year warranty.
One of the things I like most about this toilet lid is that it's very easy to install. It comes with all the necessary hardware, and I was able to install it in just a few minutes. It's also very easy to clean. The surface is smooth and non-porous, so it resists stains and bacteria. However, it's important to note that the lid may not fit all toilet tanks perfectly. It's important to measure your toilet tank before ordering to make sure that the lid will fit.

PROS
- Whisper-quiet operation during opening and closing due to the Quiet-Close feature.
- Contoured design for added seating comfort.
- Secure grip provided by the Grip-Tight Bumpers.
CONS
- May not fit all toilet bowl shapes.
- Replacing the lid may require additional tools.
The KOHLER 4636-RL-0 Cachet ReadyLatch Toilet Seat offers a premium replacement option for your toilet lid, prioritizing both comfort and functionality. Its Quiet-Close feature ensures a gentle and noise-free operation, eliminating the startling slam of traditional toilet seats. The contoured design adds an extra layer of seating comfort, making it ideal for extended bathroom sessions.
The Grip-Tight Bumpers provide a secure and stable seat, minimizing the risk of wobbling or slipping. However, it's worth noting that the seat may not be compatible with every toilet bowl shape, so it's crucial to check the dimensions before making a purchase. Installation is straightforward, but you may need additional tools other than those included in the package.

PROS
- Durable enameled wood construction ensures longevity and resistance to wear and tear.
- Fits standard round toilets, making it a versatile replacement option.
CONS
- May not be as comfortable as higher-end toilet seats.
- Color options are limited to white, which may not match all bathroom décor.
Elevate your bathroom with the durable and affordable BEMIS 400TTA 000 Economy Toilet Seat. Crafted from enameled wood, this seat withstands daily wear and tear, ensuring long-lasting use. Designed for round toilets, it offers a seamless fit, making upgrades effortless. While its primary color is white, it blends seamlessly with most bathroom styles.
This economical choice prioritizes practicality over plush comfort. However, it remains a sturdy and long-lasting option, providing a functional and affordable upgrade for your bathroom.

PROS
- Constructed with durable wood material for long-lasting use and a classic look.
- Easy to install and remove for effortless cleaning and maintenance.
CONS
- Some users may find the price to be higher than other toilet seats on the market.
The KOHLER Stonewood Quiet-Close Round Toilet Lid is an excellent choice for those seeking a combination of comfort, durability, and style. Crafted from sturdy wood, this toilet seat ensures longevity and a timeless aesthetic that complements any bathroom decor. Its slow-close functionality operates smoothly and quietly, eliminating bothersome slamming noises and ensuring a peaceful bathroom experience.
Installing and removing the seat is a hassle-free process, making cleaning and maintenance a breeze. Its secure fit prevents shifting or wobbling, providing stability and comfort during use. The well-crafted design ensures a snug fit on most standard round toilets, making it a versatile option for various bathroom configurations. Homeowners will appreciate the added touch of elegance and functionality that the KOHLER Stonewood Quiet-Close Round Toilet Lid brings to their bathrooms. While it may come with a slightly higher price tag compared to other toilet seats, its exceptional quality and the convenience it offers make it a worthwhile investment for those seeking a comfortable and stylish bathroom upgrade.

PROS
- Durable wood construction ensures longevity and sturdiness.
- Color-matched plastic hinges complement the seat and resist corrosion.
- Round shape fits most standard toilets, providing a comfortable and universal fit.
CONS
- May require additional hardware for installation, which may not be included.
- Wood material may be susceptible to moisture over time, so it's important to keep it dry.
Upgrade your bathroom with the KOHLER 4648-0 Stonewood Round Toilet Seat Replacement. Made from durable wood, this toilet seat is built to last. Its color-matched plastic hinges not only complement the seat's classic white finish but also resist corrosion, ensuring long-lasting functionality. The round shape of this toilet seat replacement makes it suitable for most standard toilets, offering a comfortable and universal fit. While it may require additional hardware for installation, the resulting upgrade will provide both durability and comfort to your bathroom.
The KOHLER 4648-0 Stonewood Toilet Seat Replacement is an excellent choice for those seeking a combination of style and practicality. Its durable construction and corrosion-resistant hinges guarantee longevity, while its round shape ensures a comfortable fit.

PROS
- Durable plastic construction ensures longevity and resilience.
- Closed front design provides privacy and hygiene.
CONS
- May not fit all toilet bowls.
The Centoco Elongated Toilet Seat is the perfect replacement for your old, worn-out toilet lid. Made of durable plastic, this toilet seat is built to last and withstand the wear and tear of daily use. The closed front design provides privacy and hygiene, making it a great choice for bathrooms of all sizes.
Installing the Centoco Elongated Toilet Seat is a breeze. Simply remove your old toilet lid and replace it with the new one. The seat is adjustable, so you can customize it to fit your toilet perfectly. Once it's installed, you'll enjoy a comfortable and secure seat every time you use the bathroom.

PROS
- Durable construction: Made from solid wood, ensuring long-lasting performance.
- Easy installation: Simple to fit and remove, providing hassle-free maintenance.
CONS
- Limited color options: Available in a single color, which may not suit all bathroom aesthetics.
- Pricey compared to basic models: The cost may be higher than some lower-priced alternatives.
Enhance your bathroom comfort and style with the Centoco Wooden Toilet Seat. Crafted from durable wood, this toilet lid replacement offers a comfortable and solid seating surface. Its closed-front design provides a clean and modern look to your bathroom decor. The easy-to-install mechanism allows for effortless removal and reinstallation, making cleaning and maintenance a breeze. While its color options are limited, the Crane White finish imparts a classic and versatile touch.
The Centoco Wooden Toilet Seat is a worthwhile investment for those seeking a durable and stylish upgrade for their bathroom. Its solid construction ensures longevity, while the closed-front design adds a touch of sophistication. The installation process is simple and convenient, enhancing its overall user-friendliness. However, it is worth noting that its price point may be higher compared to basic models, and the limited color options may not accommodate all bathroom aesthetics. Nonetheless, the Centoco Wooden Toilet Seat is a reliable choice for those seeking a combination of comfort, durability, and style in their bathroom upgrade.
In this guide, we've covered everything you need to know about toilet lid replacements. We've discussed the different types of toilet lids, the features to look for, and the best products on the market. We hope this guide has helped you find the perfect toilet lid replacement for your needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the different types of toilet lids?
There are two main types of toilet lids: elongated and round. Elongated lids are oval-shaped and extend about 2 inches beyond the bowl, while round lids are circular and fit snugly against the bowl. Elongated lids are generally more comfortable to use, but they may not fit all toilets. Round lids are more compact and easier to clean, but they may not be as comfortable to use as elongated lids.
What features should I look for in a toilet lid?
When choosing a toilet lid, there are a few key features to look for. First, make sure that the lid fits your toilet bowl properly. The lid should fit snugly against the bowl without any gaps. Second, choose a lid that is made from a durable material, such as plastic, wood, or metal. Durable materials will last longer and are less likely to break or crack.. Third, consider the style of the lid. Some lids are designed to complement the style of your bathroom, while others are more basic. Choose a lid that matches your taste and the décor of your bathroom
What are the best toilet lid replacements on the market?
The best toilet lid replacements on the market are those that are durable, comfortable to use, and stylish. Some of the top-rated toilet lid replacements include the Bemis 1500EC 390 Lift-Off Wood Elongated Toilet Seat, the Kohler K-20110-0 Brevia Elongated Toilet Seat with Grip-Tight Bumpers, and the Mayfair Caswell Modern Toilet Seat.
How do I install a toilet lid?
Installing a toilet lid is a relatively easy process. First, remove the old toilet lid by lifting it straight up. Then, align the new toilet lid with the toilet bowl and lower it into place. Make sure that the lid is seated properly and that there are no gaps between the lid and the bowl. Finally, tighten the nuts on the underside of the lid to secure it in place.
How do I clean a toilet lid?
To clean a toilet lid, simply wipe it down with a damp cloth. You can use a mild soap or cleaner if necessary. Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive cleaners, as these can damage the lid.













